City EDS V Manchester United reserves Manchester Senior Cup final match report - Manchester City FC

Accessibility links

Access other Manchester City products


Continue to

Continue to
  • Manchester City

    City 0

  • Manchester United

    Man Utd 2

    W. Keane 26mins, Giverin 93mins

  • Match reports
  • 17 May 2012 21:00
  • Posted by Mark Booth
  • Share this:
  • Share
  • Link
  • Tweet
  • +1
  • Email this
  • More channels

City’s hopes of sealing a second piece of silverware in four days were dashed after goals from Will Keane and Luke Giverin saw Manchester United retain the Manchester Senior Cup at the Etihad Stadium.

Patrick Vieira was in the stands to see if City could stage a repeat of the EDS’ 4-2 victory in their last meeting but it was Manchester United who walked away with the trophy despite a late rally from the home side.

It was the first match to be played at the Etihad Stadium since Sunday’s drama and, because of this, it’s perhaps unsurprising that the game took a while to get going.

City’s best effort of the night came on 15 minutes courtesy of the impressive Denis Suarez, who combined with Omar Elabdellaoui to great effect, only for his effort to whistle inches over the bar.

Denis Suarez was excellent for the EDS

United broke the deadlock after 26 minutes with a powerful strike from Will Keane who was played in behind the City defence from a neat flick by Davide Petrucci.

EDS manager Andy Welsh had clearly briefed his midfield to exchange positions in an attempt to unsettle United. Gai Assulin, Denis Suarez and Omar Elabdellaoui were fluid, switching wings and taking turns at functioning at the head of an advanced trident behind Luca Scapuzzi.

Gai Assulin for Manchester City EDS

Assulin recently returned from a successful loan spell at Brighton and he showcased the full bouquet of his prodigious talents in the first half, dribbling into several dangerous positions but the Israeli was unable to find the decisive final ball.

Despite all of the movement and intricate passing behind Scapuzzi, City failed to work the ball behind a well-organised United defence, causing the Italian to spend long stretches of the first half isolated.

City’s full-backs Reece Wabara and Jeremy Helan shone after the break, with their marauding runs proving to be a constant source of menace to the United defence.

With time running out, United manager Warren Joyce looked to his bench for defensive reinforcements as City threw Karim Rekik and Reece Wabara forward but United always seemed to have a defender on hand to close down, block and win headers to repel City’s waves of attacks.

Jeremy Helan's runs were a feature for the EDS

In the last 10 minutes, Helan’s lung-busting bursts down the left looked like the the Blues' most likely provider of another dramatic finale at the Etihad Stadium but it was United who doubled their lead with seconds remaining.

Substitute Luke Giverin broke clear to get on the end of a reverse pass from Will Keane to fire past Eirik Johansen as United capitalised on City's cavalry charge.

It was a disappointing end to the evening for the 5000 fans that congregated at the Etihad Stadium but there was still plenty of encouraging moments for Andy Welsh to reflect on going into the summer break.

Match details

Thursday 17 May 2012, 7:00PM

Manchester Senior Cup

Mr M. Ackerman


Manchester City:

Johansen, Wabara, Facey (Tse 78mins), Rekik, Helan, Huws, Razak, Elabdellaoui, Assulin (Hiwula 60mins), Suarez, Scapuzzi

Unused subs:
F. Mancini, Halsall, Rusnak

Razak 41mins

Manchester United:

Amos, Vermijl (Giverin 89mins), Fryers, Tunnicliffe, Wooton, M. Keane, Brady (Fornasier 81mins), Pogba, W. Keane, Petrucci (Thorpe 68mins), Lingard

Unused subs:
Johnstone, Brown

Tunnicliffe 35mins

All times are taken from a live feed and are approximate at time of publishing.
  • Share this:
  • Share
  • Link
  • Tweet
  • +1
  • Email this
  • More channels

This site uses cookies. By clicking allow you are agreeing to our use of cookies.